For anyone venturing into the world of bamboo fly rod building, choosing the right tools is critical. Two of the most prominent tools rod builders rely on are the Morgan Hand Mill and Bellinger Planning Forms. Both serve the same ultimate purpose—shaping the bamboo strips into precise, tapered forms—but they do so in distinct ways, each offering advantages and challenges. In this blog post, we'll explore the differences between these two tools, helping you decide which is the best fit for your bamboo rod-building journey.
What Are They?
Morgan Hand Mill: Invented by Tom Morgan, a legendary rod maker, the Morgan Hand Mill is a precision tool designed to shape bamboo strips into perfectly tapered pieces for bamboo fly rods. It's a more recent innovation in the world of bamboo rod building and is prized for its ability to produce consistent results without relying on traditional steel planning forms.
Bellinger Planning Forms: The Bellinger Planning Forms are a more traditional approach to shaping bamboo for rod building. The tool consists of two metal bars that can be adjusted with screws to create the desired taper, allowing rod builders to use a hand plane to shape the bamboo strips. The Bellinger brand is well-known for producing high-quality, durable planning forms that have become a staple in bamboo rod building.
Key Differences
1. Precision and Consistency
Morgan Hand Mill: One of the standout features of the Morgan Hand Mill is its ability to produce highly consistent tapers across multiple sections of bamboo. The mill allows you to cut both straight and spiral tapers with accuracy, reducing the margin for error. It’s particularly popular among rod makers who want the flexibility to work with more complex rod designs. With its precise control, builders can achieve tapers that are difficult to create with traditional hand planes.
Bellinger Planning Forms: While Bellinger Planning Forms offer a high level of precision, they rely heavily on the skill and experience of the rod builder. Adjusting the forms to achieve the desired taper takes a bit more time and finesse, and the process of using a hand plane introduces more variability compared to the Morgan Hand Mill. That said, many experienced builders prefer the hands-on feel and control that planning forms provide, and with practice, excellent results can be achieved.
2. Ease of Use
Morgan Hand Mill: The Morgan Hand Mill is more beginner-friendly when it comes to consistency, but there is a learning curve involved in setting it up and understanding how to adjust the settings for different rod tapers. However, once you master the system, the mill makes it easier to achieve precise cuts without needing to make constant adjustments. The mechanical aspect of the mill also reduces the amount of physical effort needed compared to using a hand plane.
Bellinger Planning Forms: Planning forms, on the other hand, require more manual labor and fine-tuning. The process involves using a hand plane to manually shape the bamboo, and achieving the desired taper is all about careful adjustments to the forms. This tool gives rod builders a more tactile, traditional experience, which some find more rewarding, though it can be more physically demanding and time-consuming.
3. Versatility
Morgan Hand Mill: One of the major advantages of the Morgan Hand Mill is its versatility. It allows rod builders to create a wide variety of rod tapers, from standard designs to more complex, custom tapers. Additionally, the mill can be used to create both hexagonal and quadrate rods, making it a more flexible tool for those looking to experiment with different rod shapes.
Bellinger Planning Forms: While the Bellinger Planning Forms are highly effective for producing standard hexagonal rods, they are less versatile when it comes to creating non-traditional rod shapes like quadrates. That being said, for builders who prefer to focus on classic rod designs, the planning forms are more than sufficient.
4. Cost
Morgan Hand Mill: The Morgan Hand Mill is generally more expensive upfront compared to traditional planning forms. However, the precision, versatility, and reduced need for additional tools can make it a worthwhile investment for those serious about rod building. For hobbyists who plan to make many rods or those who want to experiment with different designs, the Morgan Hand Mill can provide long-term value.
Bellinger Planning Forms: Planning forms, including the Bellinger models, are typically more affordable than the Morgan Hand Mill. However, keep in mind that with planning forms, you will need additional tools such as a high-quality hand plane and sharpening equipment, which can add to the overall cost. For builders who want a more traditional, hands-on experience, the initial investment in planning forms may be more attractive.
5. Craftsmanship Experience
Morgan Hand Mill: Some builders find the Morgan Hand Mill’s mechanical approach less engaging because it removes a lot of the manual effort. On the other hand, it allows the rod maker to focus more on precision and craftsmanship in other aspects, such as finishing and fitting. For builders looking for consistency and efficiency, the Morgan Hand Mill streamlines the shaping process.
Bellinger Planning Forms: Using planning forms involves a more tactile, hands-on process. Rod makers who value the traditional craftsmanship of bamboo fly rod building often enjoy the physicality and skill involved in using a hand plane. The process can be more rewarding, as each rod section is shaped by hand. This experience appeals to those who prefer a deeper connection to the craft.
Which Tool is Right for You?
For Precision and Versatility: If you’re looking for a tool that offers precise, consistent results with the flexibility to experiment with various rod designs, the Morgan Hand Mill is an excellent choice. It is particularly suited for rod builders who plan to make multiple rods and want the ability to fine-tune their designs easily.
For Traditional Craftsmanship and Hands-On Control: If you’re a builder who enjoys the traditional aspects of handcrafting bamboo fly rods and wants to focus on classic rod designs, the Bellinger Planning Forms may be the better fit. They offer a more immersive and tactile experience, ideal for those who appreciate the craftsmanship that comes with using a hand plane.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between the Morgan Hand Mill and Bellinger Planning Forms depends on your personal preferences, budget, and approach to rod building. Both tools are highly respected in the bamboo rod-building community and are capable of producing exceptional fly rods. Whether you prioritize precision and versatility or a traditional hands-on experience, either option will help you craft beautiful, functional bamboo fly rods that will serve you well on the water.
Ultimately, the best choice comes down to how you want to experience the rod-building process and what kind of rods you aspire to create. Whichever tool you choose, you'll be well on your way to joining the long tradition of bamboo fly rod makers.
Comments